Bobcat S650 vs. Caterpillar 262D: Which is Best? A Complete Comparison Guide

Choosing Between Bobcat S650 and Caterpillar 262D

When it comes to skid steer loaders, two of the most commonly compared models are the Bobcat S650 and the Caterpillar 262D. Both machines are known for their power, durability, and versatility, making them top choices in construction, agriculture, and landscaping. But which one is best for your needs?

In this guide, we'll break down the key differences between the Bobcat S650 and Caterpillar 262D in terms of performance, lifting capacity, comfort, fuel efficiency, attachments, price, and resale value. By the end, you'll have a clear understanding of which skid steer loader is the right choice for your business.

Engine Power and Performance: Which Skid Steer Packs More Punch?

One of the most crucial aspects of any skid steer is its engine power and overall performance. Here’s how the Bobcat S650 and Caterpillar 262D compare:

1. Bobcat S650: Powered by a 74.3 HP diesel engine, this model is known for its strong torque and smooth operation. Its hydraulic system delivers excellent power for lifting and digging.

2. Caterpillar 262D: Features a 74.3 HP Cat C3.3B engine, which is also turbocharged for improved performance. The high-flow hydraulic option enhances power for heavy-duty attachments.

Verdict:

Both skid steers are nearly identical in horsepower, but the Caterpillar 262D’s turbocharged engine and high-flow hydraulic option give it an edge in heavier-duty applications.

Lifting Capacity & Load Handling: Which One Can Handle More?

Another key factor is how much weight each machine can lift and handle efficiently.

1. Bobcat S650 Rated Operating Capacity (ROC): 2,690 lbs

2. Caterpillar 262D Rated Operating Capacity (ROC): 2,700 lbs

3. Bobcat S650 Lift Path: Radial lift – better suited for digging and pushing.

4. Caterpillar 262D Lift Path: Vertical lift – ideal for lifting heavier loads to higher heights.

Verdict:

If your work requires more digging, grading, or pushing, the Bobcat S650's radial lift design is better. If you need a skid steer for lifting materials to greater heights, the Caterpillar 262D’s vertical lift path is superior.

Operator Comfort & Cab Design: Which One Feels Better to Drive?

Skid steer operators spend long hours inside the cab, so comfort and usability matter.

1. Bobcat S650: Features a well-designed cab with improved visibility, a pressurized interior to reduce dust, and easy-to-use controls.

2. Caterpillar 262D: Comes with a sealed and pressurized cab, advanced joystick controls, and air-ride seat options, making it one of the most comfortable skid steers on the market.

Verdict:

The Caterpillar 262D wins in operator comfort due to its more refined cab design and joystick controls.

Fuel Efficiency & Maintenance Costs: Which Saves You More Money?

Owning a skid steer isn't just about the initial cost—fuel and maintenance expenses are major factors.

1. Bobcat S650: Features a Tier 4-compliant engine with efficient fuel consumption and easy-access maintenance points.

2. Caterpillar 262D: Offers low fuel consumption, but some users report higher maintenance costs due to complex electronics and sensors.

Verdict:

If you’re looking for lower maintenance costs, the Bobcat S650 may be the better choice. However, both models are fuel-efficient and compliant with emission standards.

Attachments & Versatility: Which One Works with More Equipment?

1. Bobcat S650: Compatible with over 70 Bobcat-approved attachments.

2. Caterpillar 262D: Works with a wide range of Cat Smart Attachments, offering greater automation and efficiency.

Verdict:

The Bobcat S650 is more versatile in terms of attachment variety, but the Caterpillar 262D’s Smart Attachments give it a tech advantage.

Price & Resale Value: Which One is the Better Long-Term Investment?

1. Bobcat S650 Base Price: $45,000 – $55,000 (new)

2. Caterpillar 262D Base Price: $50,000 – $60,000 (new)

3. Resale Value: Both brands hold value well, but Caterpillar equipment generally has a stronger resale market.

Verdict:

If upfront cost is a concern, the Bobcat S650 is more budget-friendly. However, the Caterpillar 262D has a slightly better resale value.

Pros & Cons of Bobcat S650 vs. Caterpillar 262D

Bobcat S650 Pros & Cons

✔ Lower upfront cost ✔ Great fuel efficiency ✔ Versatile with many attachments ✖ Radial lift may limit high-load applications ✖ Slightly less comfortable cab

Caterpillar 262D Pros & Cons

✔ Superior operator comfort ✔ Stronger resale value ✔ Advanced technology and Smart Attachments ✖ Higher upfront price ✖ Potentially higher maintenance costs

Conclusion: Bobcat S650 vs. Caterpillar 262D – Which is Best for You?

So, which one should you choose?

1. Choose the Bobcat S650 if: You want an affordable, fuel-efficient, and versatile skid steer that’s great for digging, grading, and general-purpose use.

2. Choose the Caterpillar 262D if: You prioritize comfort, resale value, and lifting capacity for high-reaching applications.

Both are excellent skid steers, so the best choice depends on your specific job requirements and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Which skid steer is better for heavy construction—Bobcat S650 or CAT 262D?

Both can handle heavy construction, but the Caterpillar 262D is better for lifting to higher heights, while the Bobcat S650 is great for ground-level work.

2. What is the fuel efficiency difference between Bobcat S650 and Caterpillar 262D?

The Bobcat S650 tends to be more fuel-efficient, though both are Tier 4-compliant.

3. Which model has better resale value—Bobcat or CAT?

Caterpillar 262D generally holds its value better, but both brands are known for strong resale demand.

4. Is the Bobcat S650 more affordable than the CAT 262D?

Yes, the Bobcat S650 has a lower base price, making it the more budget-friendly option.

5. Can I use the same attachments on both Bobcat S650 and Caterpillar 262D?

Some universal attachments work on both, but Caterpillar’s Smart Attachments only work with CAT models.

Whether you choose the Bobcat S650 or the Caterpillar 262D, both offer exceptional performance and durability. Evaluate your budget, job requirements, and comfort preferences before making a final decision!

Which skid steer do you prefer? Let us know in the comments below!