Case TV450 vs. Bobcat T870: Which is best?

When it comes to compact track loaders, the Case TV450 and the Bobcat T870 are two of the most popular choices among professionals. Both machines offer powerful performance and a range of features, but they cater to slightly different needs.

Performance and Power:

Engine Power: The Bobcat T870 has a slight edge with its 100 HP engine compared to the Case TV450’s 90 HP engine. This extra horsepower can be beneficial for more demanding tasks.

Rated Operating Capacity: The Case TV450 leads with a higher operating capacity of 4,500 lbs, making it suitable for heavier loads compared to the Bobcat T870’s 3,650 lbs.

Weight and Stability:

Operating Weight: The Bobcat T870 is heavier, weighing 12,760 lbs, compared to the Case TV450’s 10,610 lbs. This extra weight can offer better stability and traction.

Tipping Load: The Bobcat T870 also has a higher tipping load, which indicates its ability to handle more significant loads without tipping.

Speed and Mobility:

Travel Speed: The Case TV450 has a higher travel speed of 7.9 mph, which can improve productivity by reducing travel time between job sites compared to the T870’s 6.6 mph.

Ground Pressure: The Case TV450 exerts slightly less ground pressure (4.7 psi vs. 5.1 psi), which can be advantageous in minimizing soil disturbance and operating on softer grounds.

Fuel Capacity and Efficiency:

Fuel Tank Capacity: The Bobcat T870 has a larger fuel tank (32.7 gallons) compared to the Case TV450 (25.5 gallons), allowing for longer operation times between refueling.

Fuel Efficiency: Both models are designed to be fuel-efficient, but the T870’s larger engine and fuel tank might result in higher fuel consumption over time.

Cost:

Price: The Case TV450 is generally more affordable, with a price range of $75,000 - $85,000, while the Bobcat T870 is priced between $95,000 - $105,000. The price difference reflects the additional features and capabilities of the Bobcat T870.

User Reviews and Field Performance

Case TV450 User Experiences

Operators who have used the Case TV450 commend its powerful performance and reliability. They praise its versatility and ability to tackle a wide range of tasks with ease. Many users appreciate the spacious and comfortable cab, stating that it reduces operator fatigue during long work shifts. The TV450's lifting capacity and hydraulic controls also receive positive feedback, with operators noting their precision and smooth operation. Overall, the Case TV450 garners high user satisfaction and is held in high regard for its field performance.

Bobcat T870 User Experiences

Users of the Bobcat T870 highly appreciate its exceptional performance and versatility. They highlight its powerful engine and excellent torque, allowing for effortless operation even in challenging conditions. The T870's lift height and reach capabilities receive favorable reviews, as operators emphasize the convenience and efficiency of accessing elevated areas. Additionally, operators commend the T870's comfort features and user-friendly controls, stating that they contribute to a positive working experience. The Bobcat T870 has received praise for its reliability and praised for its overall field performance.

Cost Analysis: Is the Price Worth the Performance?

Initial Purchase Price

When considering the initial purchase price of the Case TV450 and Bobcat T870, it is essential to evaluate the overall value and performance each machine offers. The TV450 generally comes at a slightly lower price point compared to the T870, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers. However, it is crucial to consider the specific needs of the project and the long-term benefits provided by each machine.

While the initial purchase price is an important factor, it should not be the sole determining factor. Operators must weigh the performance, durability, and reliability of the machines to make an informed decision.

Operating Costs

Operating costs encompass various aspects such as fuel consumption, maintenance, and potential downtime. Both the Case TV450 and Bobcat T870 are designed to optimize fuel efficiency without compromising performance. However, the T870's innovative engine technology gives it a slight advantage, resulting in lower operating costs over time.

Maintenance costs should also be considered. Both machines offer easy access to key components, simplifying routine maintenance tasks. However, it is essential to consult manufacturer guidelines and schedule regular maintenance to maximize the lifespan and performance of these machines.

Additionally, the T870's advanced diagnostic systems contribute to minimizing unexpected breakdowns and reducing costly repairs, making it potentially more cost-effective in the long run.

Resale Value

Resale value is another significant aspect to consider when evaluating the cost-benefit analysis of the Case TV450 and Bobcat T870. Both machines are known for their durability and long-term reliability, which positively impacts their resale value.

While market conditions and machine condition play a role, both the Case TV450 and Bobcat T870 have demonstrated strong resale value over time. This ensures that operators can recoup a substantial portion of their investment if they decide to upgrade or sell their machine in the future.

Choosing between the Case TV450 and the Bobcat T870 depends on your specific needs and budget. The Case TV450 offers a higher operating capacity and faster travel speed at a more affordable price, making it an excellent choice for those who need efficient, high-capacity performance without breaking the bank.

On the other hand, the Bobcat T870 provides more engine power, greater stability with its higher weight, and a larger fuel tank for extended operations, which justifies its higher price for those needing extra power and durability.

Both models are excellent choices, but evaluating your specific requirements will help you determine which loader best suits your needs.